Comments on: Kurdish Girl Stoned to Death

By: thanks!

thanks! — Wed, 10 Mar 2010 01:31:07 +0000

i think this post was awesome, and made me feel slightly better after being so sickened from this video. i agree with you one hundred percent and you have motivated me to be a better person. I am a stranger, we will never meet, and yet you have made an impact on me from this little post in the void that is the internet. you have encouraged me to make a bigger effort to treat everyone with kindness and respect –> what im saying is you have made a difference in this world for the better even if its small! let's all keep trying!

By: saddened

saddened — Wed, 10 Mar 2010 01:19:17 +0000

ok so you are saying you want to murder everyone in the whole middle east? that mean you would want to murder this girl if she was still alive.

hate is not the answer.

By: saddened

saddened — Wed, 10 Mar 2010 00:59:02 +0000

many 'honor killings' come about because the girl is raped (consider the case where the 13 year old girl was stoned to death as a punishment for being raped by 3 men). this was not the case in this situation but if you can watch that video and say that stoning is a just punishment then you are a depraved and sad individual. I am curious as to what has made you think this way? have you been surrounded by violence a lot in your life so as to have become desensitized? do you live in a war torn country? i ask this because i would like to understand where you are coming from so that something useful can come out of this conversation. maybe understanding will encourage change.

I am not against any religion, im against the abuse of religion. stoning in the name of religion is an OFFENSE to that religion! it brings it down and destroys its core! how can you expect your religion to survive if it is used as an excuse for such a tragedy?? Anyone who does such a thing in the name of their religion does not understand their religion!! the problem here is ignorance and minds destroyed by brutal lives. this is what happens in war torn countries… its nothing to do with race or religion… poverty and corruption ruins culture and religion – it ruins people – that is why they become capable of such violence & lack of compassion.

we must all keep trying to change the world even if it seem hopeless. it is all worth it if it saves one life.

do not try to fight hate with hate. To respond by demeaning others' religion or culture only perpetuates hate & makes things worse.

brother of islam, you talk about crime in london etc as a justification for this act. yes there is violent crime in london – the difference is, its treated as a CRIME. its not accepted or brushed under the carpet. you can not KILL in HONOR. And there is crime in saudia arabia too my friend. there is crime everywhere. do you think that a wife being beaten regularly by her husband is a crime? im curious to know if you think that is a crime.

brother of islam – you believe that this is a just punishment. could you yourself beat that 17 year old to death, watching as her nose gets crushed into her skull and her eyeballs fall out?! you support it, could you do it? what right do you have? if you believe in that a haram should not be committed then trust your god to punish her in the next life. no man or woman has the right to take matters into their own hands in this way.

brother of islam, the quran does not support or justify this kind of thing. to say that it does is an offense to islam.

By: irish marty

irish marty — Tue, 09 Mar 2010 09:23:02 +0000

sick sick people hope they all die a slow horrible death

By: Brother of islam

Brother of islam — Sun, 07 Mar 2010 19:45:04 +0000

i agree with you sister, this rule is good.. stoning people to death because it stops them from committing this haram thing against islam in the future. the quran specifically said ' women may not have any contact with men other than their partner. ' you cannot have sex before marriage'. this is haram and this is what the kurdish girl committed. she knew that was the rule but she thought that she could get away. this rule is good unlike the christians the have murder, rape and violence all due to boyfriend and girlfriends! that is why here in saudia arabia our people live on while we watch the idiotic londoners to friends kill each other over a guy that they wont ever see in their lives agian!

By: Muslim ummah

Muslim ummah — Sun, 07 Mar 2010 19:39:24 +0000

there god is not a son of a bitch you stupid bastard … ! in saudia arabia and turkey anyone who commits adultery, sex before marriage and crime get stoned to death … this makes people frightened and not do it. i think they shouldnt have stripped her but just beat her.

By: us resident

us resident — Sat, 06 Mar 2010 04:49:03 +0000

Here is my two cents. First off, most of the people commenting on this page are either idiots or completely misguided. This is and was a horrible crime, and yes everyone who took part in this should get much worse then this innocent girl. That being said, how quick people are to point fingers and not acknowledge the garbage outside their own front doors. We have Arabs on here pointing fingers at Kurds and Yezidi's (Really, honor killings don't happen in Arab Countries? Saudi Arabia does not even have a law against it. The Kurds are actually one of the only groups in the middle east to have punishable laws against such crimes. Granted they should actually use that law much more then they currently do. We got American Sergants claiming that he will gladly put a bullet in someone (Right, because heinous crimes and these ass backwards cults don't exist in the United States?.) These so called Honor killings are sick, I don't condone it whatsoever, I completely agree that it is a major problem and should be dealt with extreme force. I actually for one have wrote an entire script on this subject hoping that I can re-teach some of these animals who participate in such traditions, but please, all you righteous people. Every religion does not come without its brutal actions towards the innocent ones. All, not just Islam. In the united states and other parts of the western world, you have other sick crimes that don't happen in that part of the world. The child molestation, sexual abuse, serial murderers, children that show up at school and murder innocent students is staggering in the western world. The heinous crimes in the middle east need to stop, but please look outside your own front door, and at the very least acknowledge the sick shit that happens in your own backyards while you take such careful notice of the others.

By: not all middle eastern peaople are muslim

not all middle eastern peaople are muslim — Fri, 05 Mar 2010 17:36:36 +0000

any body who say anything about any religion- because of what they watched- should think twice before saying it. islam is not much different than cristianty or jewism. you would see the stories about “stonning” not only in Islam, but also in Cristianity and Jewism. ( if you read all the books)
i invite you all to research the news about this video and see what, and why is that happened.
i am a 30 years old man cried with non-stop tears while watching this video. ( usually you know guys don’t cry that much)
I guess my heart can’t bear it for a second time.
if you read the news you will see that this poor beautiful young lady was punished by her so cold “family” or community- a 1000 of useless, heartless, brainlessno words invented to describe them- who were non-muslims, so called “Yezidi” another middle eastern tribal religion. the reason was because she loved a Muslim.
may god forgive her sins and pride her into his heaven.

By: emal

emal — Fri, 05 Mar 2010 13:39:07 +0000

u r all animals wat was her crime bosted kurdish

By: TheOneWhoCares

TheOneWhoCares — Fri, 05 Mar 2010 10:10:20 +0000

Oh My Goodness. Please people stop blaming ISLAM and Muslims for this! Dont just jump to conlusians your just Pathetic. Her Murders were none Muslim okay. INSHALLA she is in heaven. x